• 14 October, 1999Counting since:
  • 1111878Total site visitors:
  • 428Visitors today:
  • 0Visitors currently online:
  • 541Visitors to this post:
Home Erin's Journal, Posts, Reviews Review Guidelines


Review Guidelines

These are the standard guidelines I have for any book for review. If you have a specific question about these, please contact me.

  1. My specialty is Wicca (specifically Seax-Wica), Druidism, magick and ritual. This is the focus of my website, so if you send me books, please try to send them in those areas of specialty. I probably won’t be able to accurately critique a book on Gypsies, as I have no background in that area (for example).
  2. I post my reviews to multiple forums. Generally they go to the update list for my website, Alt.Religion.Wicca.Moderated, WitchesThree@yahoogroups.com, and any of up to 7 specialty lists for my various interests. I also permanently post a copy to my website, and generally I get asked to share the review with about 3 to 5 other lists that I’m not a member of. The review gets decent market saturation fairly quickly, but if it’s a bad review, it could drop sales significantly. That I know of, I have had an average of 3 people per review base their buying decisions on my review. My website gets an average of 25 NEW visitors every day, with approximately 50 return visitors per day. Keep those traffic stats in mind.
  3. I WILL NOT review any book by Mark Ventimiglia. Don’t send them because I will not review it, and that’s just wasting trees.
  4. I will send copies of the review to you, the publisher, as long as I have an email address, and to the author if I can find an email address on them (or if you give it to me) along with the URL and a list of where the reviews were posted.
  5. All copies of a review are posted simultaneously. No advanced copies will be available.
  6. Any book for review should be sent to:

    c/o Daven’s Journal
    (email me for address)

    Please include contact information for the editor or publicist who is handling this book, as well as any promotional materials you feel to be relevant.

  7. I may occasionally come up with a list of questions for the author. This is not an interview, it is a chance for the author to clarify points of concern before the review is written. However, in the time I have written reviews, this has only happened twice.
  8. I must say this, even though it should be obvious. I call a spade a spade in a review. I will take into consideration the age of the author and how many books they have published and I may lighten a bad review a little, to try to encourage them to continue with their writing, but if a book is bad or I have a problem with a section of the book, I will say so. My readers count on my honesty and integrity. I will say what I like and what I didn’t like about the books in the review.
  9. At any one time I have at least four books waiting for review, and I have had up to 20. As such I generally skim the books in the order I receive them in. If you wish me to review a book in advance of it’s publication, please say so and give me a date for release. As part of that, if this is a review in advance of publication, I can and will send extra copies of the review to others of your choice. Simply include their email addresses in the publicity materials. I can’t do this very often, so use this sparingly if you wish me to do this. ๐Ÿ˜‰

Any comments you may have on these reviews, I would like to hear at daven@erinsjournal

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

User Login

Upcoming Holidays & Events

  • Tue, Mar 9
    • Day of Olvir
  • Thu, Mar 11
    • Creation Day
  • Sun, Mar 14
    • Daylight Saving Time starts
  • Wed, Mar 17
    • St. Patrick's Day
    • End of Ash Celtic tree month
  • Thu, Mar 18
    • Start Alder Celtic tree month
  • Sat, Mar 20
    • High Feast of Ostara
    • Venus In The Morning
    • 3:37a - March Equinox
  • Sun, Mar 21
    • Spring Equinox (Ostara) Lesser Sabbat, Quarter Day
    • Spring Equinox (Ostara) Lesser Sabbat, Quarter Day
  • Wed, Mar 24
    • Canton's Birthday!
  • Sun, Mar 28
    • Ragnar Lodbrok`s Day
  • Sun, Apr 4
    • Easter Sunday
  • Mon, Apr 5
    • Easter Monday
  • Fri, Apr 9
    • Day of Jarl Hakon
  • Wed, Apr 14
    • End of Alder Celtic tree month

Subscribe to the Journal

Enter your email address to subscribe to Erin's Journal and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Current Moon Phase

The Moon